Is the IMO Net-Zero Framework Anchored or Adrift?
Navigating the Proposed Paths to Zero
Copyright: PtX Lab Lausitz
PtX Lab Analysis I 11/2026 I Topic: Shipping I 53 Pages
The PtX Lab Analysis Is the IMO Net-Zero Framework Anchored or Adrift? Navigating the Proposed Paths to Zero examines the original draft of the Net-Zero Framework (NZF) for international shipping, as well as the five proposed amendments currently under discussion at the International Maritime Organisation (IMO). This economic analysis focuses on the incentive structure and the economic efficiency of the proposed regulation.
The analysis is published at a crucial juncture: at the end of November 2026, the Interim Working Group on the Reduction of Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Ships (ISWG-GHG 23) will meet, followed by the 85th session of the Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC 85, 30 November to 3 December 2026). This could be the final round of negotiations before a decision is taken on the adoption of the new framework.
The analysis shows that the original draft combines two performance standards with an emissions trading scheme (ETS).
This leads to unnecessary costs and planning uncertainty, even though the ETS element supports environmentally friendly ships through a direct income transfer. A key finding is a loophole in the draft: if the price of Surplus Units (SU) is below 100 USD, a ship that fails to meet both performance standards pays a lower emissions price for an emissions-intensive fuel than a ship that fails to meet only the more ambitious standard.
Shipping companies would thus have an incentive to deploy the less clean ship, which runs counter to the purpose of the regulation. The proposals from Australia et al. and Brazil, which are based on the original draft, are also affected. The alternative proposals from Brazil, Tuvalu, Liberia and Japan each address different weaknesses in the draft.
Although the original draft of the NZF has some shortcomings, the authors recommend that it be adopted by MEPC 85 in December 2026 and subsequently at the resumption of the second extraordinary session of the MEPC on Friday 4 December 2026 (MEPC/ES.2). The loophole in question could be remedied quite easily in the original draft, as could other minor amendments currently under discussion at the IMO due to the delay in the adoption process.
An immediate and clear regulatory framework is required to ensure planning certainty regarding emission costs and thus to steer investment towards clean technologies. The longer the adoption of the NZF is delayed, the more investment decisions will be made on the basis of expected future regulation. As investors factor in the possibility that the NZF may not be adopted, they will tend to favour conventional technologies. Such vessels would remain in service for decades to come, which would severely hinder the decarbonisation of the shipping sector.
However, as further negotiations may take place next year, the PtX Lab Lausitz has developed its own proposal for more substantial changes, combining a single performance standard with an ETS element. This would make the regulatory framework simpler and more economically efficient, whilst removing the unintended incentive present in the original draft. The performance standard would generate revenue for the Net-Zero Fund, whilst the ETS element would directly support clean ships.
Bibliographic data
- Publication: Is the IMO Net-Zero Framework Anchored or Adrift? Navigating the Proposed Paths to Zero
- Publication date: November 2026
- Publisher: PtX Lab Lausitz – Think-and-Do-Tank für Kraft- und Grundstoffe aus grünem Wasserstoff, Calauer Straße 70, D-03048 Cottbus
- Authors: Dr Gilbert Kollenbach, Anita Demuth and Felix Schmermer
- Suggested citation: PtX Lab Lausitz (2026): Is the IMO Net-Zero Framework Anchored or Adrift? Navigating the Proposed Paths to Zero
Contact
Anita Demuth
Head of Section PtX Mobility
+49 152 28 400 735
Write E-Mail
more information
Contact
Dr
Gilbert Kollenbach
Expert
+49 355 478 892 08
Write E-Mail
more information